Where a child or vulnerable adult dies as a result of abuse in the home, it may not be possible to prove beyond reasonable doubt which of the adults caring for the child or vulnerable adult inflicted the fatal injuries. As a result, the party who killed the child or vulnerable adult, and a party who stood by and allowed it to happen, may literally "get away with murder" in some cases. In other jurisdictions, new criminal offences and rules of procedure have been introduced to counter this. In England, for example, section 5 of the Domestic Violence, Crime and Victims Act 2004 allows the court to convict and imprison for up to 14 years those who have caused the death of a child or vulnerable adult or should have known that the child or vulnerable adult was at significant risk of serious harm and failed to take reasonable steps to prevent that harm. South Australia enacted legislation along broadly similar lines in 2005 and a more recent reform model came into operation in New Zealand in 2012.
To consider whether reform may be required to the law in Hong Kong, the subject of causing or allowing the death of a child or vulnerable adult was referred to the Law Reform Commission in September 2006 and a sub-committee was established in November 2006 under the chairmanship of the late Mr Alexander King, SC. Its current members (in alphabetical order) are:
| Ms Amanda Whitfort, Associate Professor, Faculty of Law, University of Hong Kong (Chairman) |
| Dr Philip Beh, Associate Professor, Department of Pathology, University of Hong Kong |
| Ms Diane Crebbin, Barrister, former Senior Public Prosecutor, Department of Justice |
| Mr Chan Tat Ming, Neil, Senior Superintendent of Police, Crime Wing, Hong Kong Police Force |
| Mr Stephen Hung, Partner, Li & Partners |
| Ms Lee Kam Yung Dora, Chief Social Work Officer (Domestic Violence), Social Welfare Department |
| Ms Jacqueline Leong, SC, Barrister |
| Ms Lisa Remedios, Barrister |
| Mr John Saunders, SBS, former Judge of the Court of First Instance of the High Court |
The Sub-committee's Secretary is Ms Louisa Ng, Senior Government Counsel.
The Sub-committee published a consultation paper in May 2019 to invite public views on the preliminary proposals for reform of the law relating to the criminal liability of parents, carers and others when children or vulnerable adults die or are seriously harmed as a result of abuse or neglect while in their care. The Commission issued a report in September 2021 recommending the introduction of a new offence of “failure to protect a child or vulnerable person where the child's or vulnerable person’s death or serious harm results from an unlawful act or neglect”.